Buy Tickets for O’Connell & Company’s 25th Season
25th Anniversary Ultimate Pass


5 Main Stage Shows & 3 Sheas Smith Shows & 1 Night only Curtain Up! Production

Main Stage Pass

5 Main Stage Shows 

Total DIVA Pass

All 4 DIVA Shows 

Don’t miss this incredible season!
Flex Pass

6 Pack of Main Stage Show

Want to catch it all?        
 Tickets for our 25th Anniversary Ultimate Season Pass on sale now! For assistance call 716-848-0800
ANNOUNCING our 25th Anniversary Ultimate Season Pass!

For our 25th Anniversary season we are proud to announce a few new and exciting projects, including the WNY premier of ‘Young Frankenstein.’ This is the first-time the London version of the musical will be available. O’Connell & Company will also bring back some of our all-time favorite productions from the past two decades – including a reprise role of Mary Kate O’Connell in ‘Glorious! The True Story of Florence Foster Jenkins, The Worst Singer in the World.’This season will also feature, Melissa Leventhal (2019 Artie Nominee for Outstanding Actress in a Musical) as Patsy Cline, in a ‘Closer Walk with Patsy Cline,’ as well as a reprisal of our smash hit, ‘NUNSENSE A-Men,’ featuring an all-male cast of our favorite sisters.

We are extremely excited to bring you this incredible line-up, so as a gift of our gratitude for all of your support, we are offering an Ultimate Season Pass!

For the first-time event, O’Connell & Company is including all 9 Individual Shows! Includes: all 5 Main Stage Productions, all 3 Shea’s Smith presentations and the one night only Curtain Up! production of Gentlemen Prefer DIVAS: Broadway Legends also at Shea’s Smith Theatre in one ULTIMATE pass for a reduced rate of $250 and $225 for Seniors.

ALSO, as a special gift for purchasing our 25th Anniversary ULTIMATE SEASON PASS you will also receive an O’Connell & Company tote bag with additional surprises!

This package is available for a limited time and dependent on ticket availability. Don’t wait – reserve your spot today!

NINE INDIVIDUAL SHOWS, the Ultimate Pass includes:

Curtain Up!: Gentlemen Prefer DIVAS – Broadway Legends
September 20, 2019 at Shea’s Smith Theater

The New Mel Brooks Musical: Young Frankenstein
October 3 – 27, 2019 at Ken-Ton Elmwood Commons

A Closer Walk with Patsy Cline
Feat. Melissa Leventhal as “Patsy Cline”
November 29 & 30, December 1, 6, 7, 8 at Shea’s Smith Theater

Gentlemen Prefer DIVAs: A Very DIVA Christmas
December 13, 14, and 15 at Ken-Ton Elmwood Commons

January 24, 25, 26, 31, February 1, 2, 2020 at Shea’s Smith Theater*

Glorious! The True Story of Florence Foster Jenkins, The Worst Singer in the World.
Feat. Mary Kate O’Connell as “Ms. Jenkins”
February 6 – March 1, 2020 at Ken-Ton Elmwood Commons

Betsy Carmichael’s Hawaiian Luau BINGO
An Original Interactive Comedy by Joey Bucheker & Mary Kate O’Connell
February 27, 28, 29, March 1, 2020 at Shea’s Smith Theater*

Lucky Stiff
April 16 – May 10, 2020 at Ken-Ton Elmwood Commons

Steel Magnolias
May 28 – June 21, 2020 at Ken-Ton Elmwood Commons

Arts Access Passes

Arts Access passes will only be eligible for 2 tickets during the first 2 weeks of our shows. Only 20 Arts Access passes total will be available for each performance.
Tickets are available by calling the box office Tuesday-Thursday from 10 am-2 pm.



Wednesday-Thursday-Friday-Saturday: 7:30 pm
Sunday Matinee: 2:30 pm

The Theatre Box Office opens 30 minutes before Showtime

To avoid waiting in line, we encourage you to purchase tickets in advance by calling our Business/Reservation Office or by taking advantage of our online, print-at-home ticket option via Vendini.


Comfortable and unobstructed seating is available in our spacious venue. There is OPEN SEATING, on a first-come, first-served basis. A designated area for wheelchairs is available; please ask one of our Volunteer Ushers for assistance if you or someone in your party uses a wheelchair.  We recommend advising us of any mobility issues at the time you make your reservation so that seating accommodations can be made in advance.

The Theatre BOX OFFICE will open 30 minutes prior to showtime for ticket purchases. To avoid waiting in line, we encourage you to purchase tickets in advance by calling our Business/Reservation Office or by taking advantage of our online, print-at-home ticket option via Vendini which is available 24/7 (convenience fees apply).


All ticket sales are final, whether paid by cash, check or credit card. In the event a patron cannot attend a performance for which they have purchased a ticket and they contact O’Connell & Company by telephone at least 24 hours in advance of the performance, every effort will be made to accommodate that patron by rescheduling to a different performance date or show.

If a performance is cancelled by O’Connell & Company, the patron will be rescheduled to a different performance at a date & time convenient to the patron. Refunds will not be issued. However, exchange fees & price differences (if any) will be waived. If the status of a performance does change, an announcement will be posted on the O’Connell & Company website. It will also be announced on local radio & television consistent with the stations’ policies if it is due to weather conditions.


The use of cameras or video equipment during performances is strictly prohibited due to copyright regulations. Cellphones must be turned off because they interfere with the sound equipment. We ask that you refrain from checking messages and/or texting during the performance as a courtesy to other patrons and the performers; the light from the phone’s screen is extremely distracting. We reserve the right to request that violators leave the theatre.




The Business/Reservation Office is closed on weekends and on major Holidays and during the summer break (July-August).  

The Theatre Box Office is located in the Ken-Ton Elmwood Commons.

Become a friend of O’Connell and a patron of the arts

Privacy Settings
We use cookies to enhance your experience while using our website. If you are using our Services via a browser you can restrict, block or remove cookies through your web browser settings. We also use content and scripts from third parties that may use tracking technologies. You can selectively provide your consent below to allow such third party embeds. For complete information about the cookies we use, data we collect and how we process them, please check our Privacy Policy
Consent to display content from Youtube
Consent to display content from Vimeo
Google Maps
Consent to display content from Google